# Verify a scientific calculation task


Use the [task-package specification](/data/task-packages) to choose the package layout and record evidence for the exact revision.

Pick a scientific workflow whose result can be checked independently. This example follows the numerical-workflow pattern in Terminal-Bench-Science using invented mass and volume readings. [Terminal-Bench-Science 0.1](https://www.tbench.ai/news/terminal-bench-science-0-1)

## Author and verify

State the units, blank correction, output fields and absolute tolerance before any runs. A second calculation should establish the expected answer independently of the solver's code. A Tier 1 verifier checks finite values, exact units and the error bound. Use domain review to check the interpretation of the method, then use the program to score results.

## Calibrate and correct

Run the reference and a control that skips the blank subtraction. Keep the reference calculation and the tolerance rationale with the private evidence. Record an out-of-tolerance value as a failed check and an unavailable runner as an infrastructure error. If an invalid result passes, revise the check and rerun the old and new revisions on the same cases.

## Worked example

Use Python 3.12. Subtract a 1 mg blank from a 7 mg reading and divide by 3 mL. The reference should pass. A result that skips the blank or uses the wrong unit should fail.

```bash
python3.12 - <<'PY'
from decimal import Decimal

reading, blank, volume = map(Decimal, ("7", "1", "3"))
expected = Decimal("2.00")  # independent reference: 6 mg / 3 mL
tolerance = Decimal("0.05")

def passes(value, unit):
    return unit == "mg/mL" and value.is_finite() and abs(value - expected) <= tolerance

assert passes((reading - blank) / volume, "mg/mL")
assert not passes(reading / volume, "mg/mL")
assert not passes(expected, "g/mL")
assert not passes(Decimal("NaN"), "mg/mL")
print("reference pass, uncorrected, wrong unit and non-finite values fail")
PY
```

In the package, put the independent answer and the tolerance check in the verifier. Report the numerical error with its unit so a later reviewer can compare revisions.
